The Los Angeles Post
U.S. World Business Lifestyle
Today: April 14, 2025
Today: April 14, 2025

Amazon Indigenous community wins latest stage of court battle for lost territory

Peru Kichwa Court
December 20, 2024
ED DAVEY - AP

An Indigenous community in the Peruvian Amazon is celebrating a legal victory in the latest stage of its attempt to take back claimed ancestral rainforests.

The Puerto Franco community of the Kichwa tribe say their territory was stolen to form the Cordillera Azul National Park in 2001. Companies such as Shell and TotalEnergies spent tens of millions of dollars on carbon credits in the park to counter emissions from their fossil fuel operations. The Kichwas got next to nothing and were left in hunger, despite a 2022 Associated Press investigation finding that it was almost certainly their ancestral territory, by the terms of a convention Peru signed decades ago.

The community celebrated a dramatic legal victory last year, when provincial Judge Simona del Socorro Torres Sรกnchez ruled that creating the park without their consent had violated their rights. Authorities were ordered to grant them legal ownership and proceeds from the carbon credit sales.

But that was quickly overturned by an appeals court in a move that some legal experts called questionable.

Judge Sรกnchez has now ruled once again in the Kichwasโ€™ favor, however, making a new order that the Kichwas should get their land back and benefit from the carbon credit sales. She found the Kichwas were Indigenous, and their territorial rights counted for more than the amount of time thatโ€™s passed.

The Peruvian government and a nonprofit which runs the park, CIMA, have argued that too much time has passed for the Kichwas to make a claim, and that they are not truly Indigenous people. Peruvian authorities have also argued in legal filings that the community didnโ€™t object to the parkโ€™s creation in 2001.

Kichwa leader Inocente Sangama said he was โ€œoutragedโ€ at the claim they were not Indigenous people. โ€œWho said an Indigenous person cannot wear clothes?โ€

โ€œThe justice system has proved us right,โ€ he said. โ€œWe feel pride and happiness.โ€

The AP emailed the Peruvian government but did not immediately receive a reply. Jorge Aliaga Arauco, a director at CIMA, said by email that they would appeal the decision and were on solid evidential ground. The nonprofit says proceeds from the carbon credit project help protect the ancient rainforest, one of Peruโ€™s most pristine and biodiverse environments.

The case may be moving towards a conclusion.

Juan Carlos Dรญaz, a constitutional lawyer at Pontifical Catholic University of Peru, told the AP that the ruling could be appealed before a superior court. If the Kichwas win there, the decision would be final, he said. Should the Kichwas lose, they would have one last right of appeal, to a Constitutional Court in Lima, but the government doesn't have that last recourse.

โ€”โ€”โ€”-

The Associated Pressโ€™ climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find APโ€™s standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.

Related

Americas|Business|Economy|Political

Brazil economy set to decelerate in second half of 2025 on high interest rates, trade worries: Reuters Poll

Americas|Business|Crime|Political|US

A key ally in Trump's migrant crackdown is coming for a visit. What might El Salvador's Bukele get?

Americas|Health|Political|World

Brazil's Bolsonaro in intensive care after 12-hour surgery

Americas|Business|Economy|Finance|Political|Stock Markets

Argentine peso slides after FX controls eased, bonds jump

Local

News|Local

Southern California Edison announces plan to underground power lines

News|Local

Disney to leave historic Fox Studio Lot, ending legacy

News|Local

Palisades Recreation Center to be rebuilt

Arts|Celebrity|Entertainment|Local|News|WrittenByLAPost

Weezer bassist to play Coachella despite wifeโ€™s arrest

Share This

Popular

Americas|Business|Economy|Political

Brazil economy set to decelerate in second half of 2025 on high interest rates, trade worries: Reuters Poll

Brazil economy set to decelerate in second half of 2025 on high interest rates, trade worries: Reuters Poll
Americas|Business|Crime|Political|US

A key ally in Trump's migrant crackdown is coming for a visit. What might El Salvador's Bukele get?

A key ally in Trump's migrant crackdown is coming for a visit. What might El Salvador's Bukele get?
Americas|Health|Political|World

Brazil's Bolsonaro in intensive care after 12-hour surgery

Brazil's Bolsonaro in intensive care after 12-hour surgery
Americas|Business|Economy|Finance|Political|Stock Markets

Argentine peso slides after FX controls eased, bonds jump

Argentine peso slides after FX controls eased, bonds jump

Political

Americas|Business|Crime|Political|US

A key ally in Trump's migrant crackdown is coming for a visit. What might El Salvador's Bukele get?

A key ally in Trump's migrant crackdown is coming for a visit. What might El Salvador's Bukele get?
Asia|Business|Economy|Political|US|World

China's Xi says there are no winners in a tariff war as he visits Southeast Asia

China's Xi says there are no winners in a tariff war as he visits Southeast Asia
Crime|Political|US

Suspect in arson at Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro's residence being treated at hospital, police say

Suspect in arson at Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro's residence being treated at hospital, police say
Crime|Europe|Political

UK police struggled to counter online falsehoods that fueled summer violence, lawmakers say

UK police struggled to counter online falsehoods that fueled summer violence, lawmakers say

Access this article for free.

Already have an account? Sign In