The Los Angeles Post
U.S. World Business Lifestyle
Today: March 18, 2025
Today: March 18, 2025

DACA dealt a legal setback by federal appeals court

DACA dealt a legal setback by federal appeals court
January 17, 2025

(CNN) — A federal appeals court on Friday dealt the immigration program known as DACA a legal setback, keeping the program alive but teeing up a showdown at the Supreme Court.

In a unanimous ruling, a three-judge panel of the 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the policy was unlawful but said that a federal judge in Texas had erred in concluding that the entire program should be halted nationwide. The court instead narrowed the injunction against part of the program so it would only apply to Texas.

The ruling injects fresh uncertainty for around half a million recipients of the Obama-era program that allows undocumented immigrants who were brought to the US illegally to live and work in the United States.

The appeals court kept in place a pause on a lower-court ruling that barred the government nationwide from accepting new applications to the program, meaning that for now, DACA remains largely intact.

“Because (Department of Homeland Security) intended the aspects of DACA to be severable and to function independently from one another, the district court erred by not severing the forbearance provisions from the work-authorization provisions,” Judge Jerry Smith, Ronald Reagan appointee, wrote in the ruling.

Nina Perales, vice president of litigation for MALDEF, which represents DACA recipients in the case, said it’s unclear what the court’s ruling means for DACA participants in Texas who are allowed to work.

“It’s striking down that part of the DACA rule that makes DACA recipients eligible for work authorization consideration,” Perales said.

“That answer is not provided in the decision,” Perales said, when asked whether the ruling would strip work permits away from DACA recipients. “It’s unlikely that it means a sudden end to work authorization, given that even Texas in the case was asking for a wind down.”

The court said that it would keep its ruling on hold “pending a further order of this court or the Supreme Court.” It’s unclear what the incoming Trump administration, which has shown a hostility to DACA, will decide to do with the ruling.

The Obama-era program has faced numerous legal challenges over the years. Under President Joe Biden, the program was codified through the federal rule-making process, but met with yet another challenge by a group of Republican-led states that argued the program harmed their states due to the public health care and educational spending that goes to DACA recipients.

The appeals court judges said in their ruling that the rule “is materially identical” to the program created via executive action in 2012 and contrary to federal immigration law, which they said did not give DHS the authority to set up the DACA scheme.

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2025 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

Related Articles

Federal agents are seen arresting Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil in a newly released video Fact check: Trump’s false claims on immigration, Biden, Ukraine in DOJ remarks Amid bursts of resistance, Trump administration squeezes colleges over pro-Palestinian protests as activist remains detained U.S. to probe Columbia protests for terrorism violations, official says
Share This

Popular

Election|Political|US

Start of early voting in Wisconsin Supreme Court race will test enthusiasm on both sides

Start of early voting in Wisconsin Supreme Court race will test enthusiasm on both sides
Health|MidEast|Political|World

Middle East latest: More than 400 killed as Israel launches airstrikes across Gaza

Middle East latest: More than 400 killed as Israel launches airstrikes across Gaza
Crime|Education|MidEast|Political|US

Detained Columbia University student disputes government's 'bedbugs' claim in court papers

Detained Columbia University student disputes government's 'bedbugs' claim in court papers
Health|MidEast|Political|World

Israeli strikes across Gaza kill at least 413 Palestinians and shatter ceasefire with Hamas

Israeli strikes across Gaza kill at least 413 Palestinians and shatter ceasefire with Hamas

Political

Asia|Crime|Political|World

Indian city sets curfew after Hindu groups demand demolition of 17th century Muslim ruler's tomb

Indian city sets curfew after Hindu groups demand demolition of 17th century Muslim ruler's tomb
Europe|MidEast|Political|US|World

Trump set to speak to Putin as White House looks to close ceasefire deal between Russia and Ukraine

Trump set to speak to Putin as White House looks to close ceasefire deal between Russia and Ukraine
Business|Economy|Finance|Political|US

Trump is blaming Biden for a weakening economy. Is that fair?

Trump is blaming Biden for a weakening economy. Is that fair?
Business|Economy|Europe|Political

Europe's increased defence spending to prop up growth, ECB's Rehn says

Europe's increased defence spending to prop up growth, ECB's Rehn says

Access this article for free.

Already have an account? Sign In