The Los Angeles Post
U.S. World Business Lifestyle
Today: April 10, 2025
Today: April 10, 2025

Hundreds of fraudulent votes cast in prestigious science fiction prize

July 23, 2024
Louis Mian - CNN

(CNN) โ€” Hundreds of votes were cast fraudulently for one finalist in the prestigious Hugo Awards, which honors the best science fiction and fantasy works of the previous year, its administrative team has revealed.

Nearly 10% of votes were deemed fraudulent, with 377 out of 3,813 votes being disqualified.

Many votes were made under โ€œobvious fake names,โ€ the Hugo Awardsโ€™ administrators said in a statement Monday, explaining that there was โ€œa run of voters whose second names were identical except that the first letter was changed, in alphabetical order,โ€ as well as a โ€œrun of voters whose names were translations of consecutive numbers.โ€

Suspicions grew further as a large number of these votes were cast for one candidate in particular, who administrators have chosen not to name, citing a lack of evidence that they were aware of the ruse. They have instead been dubbed โ€œFinalist A.โ€

โ€œThis pattern of data is startlingly and obviously different from the votes for any other finalist in 2024, and indeed for any finalist in any of the previous years,โ€ the administrative team said.

The Hugo Awards can only be voted on by members of the World Science Fiction Society, who gather at annual conventions commonly known as โ€œWorldcon,โ€ which brings together science fiction enthusiasts from around the globe.

A membership for the World Science Fiction Society costs about $58 (ยฃ45), meaning the membership fees to cast 377 fraudulent votes would cost about $21,900 (ยฃ16,960).

The awards team said it had received a โ€œconfidential reportโ€ that one person had been sponsoring others to join the convention and vote for their preferred candidate.

โ€œFinalist Aโ€ did not win their category once the discredited votes had been removed, according to the administrators.

The Hugo Awards, established in 1953, has 15 categories, including best novel, best short story and best fanzine. Previous winners of the best novel category include J.K. Rowlingโ€™s โ€œHarry Potter and the Goblet of Fire,โ€ Martha Wellsโ€™ โ€œNetwork Effectโ€ and N.K. Jemisinโ€™s โ€œThe Stone Sky.โ€

John Scalzi, one of this yearโ€™s finalists for his book โ€œStarter Villain,โ€ praised the Hugo Awardsโ€™ transparency in a post on his website. โ€œTo the person or persons going out of their way to try to screw around with this years Hugo: You just threw a whole lot of money into the trash, pal,โ€ Scalzi added.

The administrative team said: โ€œWe want to reassure 2024 Hugo voters that the ballots cast were counted fairly.

โ€œMost of all, we want to assure the winners of this yearโ€™s Hugos that they have won fair and square, without any arbitrary or unexplained exclusion of votes or nominees and without any possibility that their award had been gained through fraudulent means.โ€

This yearโ€™s Hugo Awards are being held in the Scottish city of Glasgow and will be hosted in Seattle, Washington, next year.

The-CNN-Wire
โ„ข & ยฉ 2024 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

Share This

Popular

Americas|Crime|Political|US|World

Ksenia Karelina, a US-Russia dual national, freed in a prisoner swap between Moscow and Washington

Ksenia Karelina, a US-Russia dual national, freed in a prisoner swap between Moscow and Washington
Crime|MidEast|Political|World

Israel releases Palestinian who took part in attack aged 13 and developed mental illness in prison

Israel releases Palestinian who took part in attack aged 13 and developed mental illness in prison
Asia|Crime|Economy|Education|MidEast|Political|World

Taliban morality enforcers arrest men for having the wrong hairstyle or skipping mosque, UN says

Taliban morality enforcers arrest men for having the wrong hairstyle or skipping mosque, UN says
Crime|Europe|Political|World

Russian drone attack injures 12 in two Ukrainian cities, officials say

Russian drone attack injures 12 in two Ukrainian cities, officials say

Crime

Americas|Crime|Entertainment|Political|Sports|World

Officials scramble to identify victims of Dominican club roof collapse that killed at least 184

Officials scramble to identify victims of Dominican club roof collapse that killed at least 184
Business|Crime|Political|Technology|US

Trump signs orders targeting two ex-officials who criticized him

Trump signs orders targeting two ex-officials who criticized him
Crime|Entertainment|Political|Sports|World

Death toll nears 200 in Dominican Republic nightclub tragedy

Death toll nears 200 in Dominican Republic nightclub tragedy
Americas|Crime|Election|Political

Ecuador's violence-hit coastal region focus of presidential candidates

Ecuador's violence-hit coastal region focus of presidential candidates

Access this article for free.

Already have an account? Sign In