The Los Angeles Post
U.S. World Business Lifestyle
Today: March 13, 2025
Today: March 13, 2025

Judge in Young Dolph murder case removes himself based on appeals court order

Rapper Killed-Young Dolph
October 27, 2023

MEMPHIS, Tenn. (AP) โ€” A judge removed himself from the Young Dolph murder case Friday after he was ordered to do so by a Tennessee appeals court, which questioned whether he could be impartial to a man charged with killing the rapper two years ago.

Shelby County Criminal Court Judge Lee Coffee asked the court clerk to assign a new judge in the high-profile case. The Tennessee Court of Appeals issued its order Sept. 28 after Coffee refused to step down at the request of the lawyer for Justin Johnson, who is charged with two other men in the fatal shooting of Young Dolph in November 2021.

The lawyer, Luke Evans, had argued that Coffee could not be impartial after the judge failed to inform him about an order limiting Johnsonโ€™s ability to communicate with people outside the jail other than Evans.

Johnson and Cornelius Smith have pleaded not guilty in the killing of Young Dolph, whose real name was Adolph Thornton Jr. The rapper, producer and independent music label owner was gunned down in a daylight ambush at a Memphis bakery, where he was buying cookies while back in is hometown to visit a sick relative and hand out Thanksgiving turkeys.

Coffee had set a March 11 trial date for Johnson and Smith, but it was not immediately clear how Coffee's recusal would affect that.

A third man, Hernandez Govan, has pleaded not guilty to organizing the killing, which shook Memphis and the entertainment world.

Evans asked for Coffeeโ€™s recusal after the judge restricted Johnsonโ€™s visitation privileges and did not allow Johnson to communicate by phone or in writing with anyone outside the jail but his lawyer, including family. Johnson was accused of using a phone call from jail to record a rap song, media outlets reported.

The judge didn't contact the defense or hold a hearing before issuing the order, which Evans called โ€œpunitive.โ€

Coffee said he issued the order for Johnsonโ€™s safety and he denied the accusations that he was not being impartial. Coffee said he had not made any judgments about Johnsonโ€™s guilt or innocence.

The judge also discussed the issue of jail recordings and their release with a law enforcement official in a phone call that the appeals court said was improper because it was not in the presence of Johnson or his lawyer. Coffee said he made the call โ€œin court, on the bench, with another case before the Court,โ€ according to the appeal ruling.

Even though the conversation โ€œdid not bear upon the alleged facts of the charges against the Defendant, it would appear to a reasonable person that Judge Coffee has a prejudiceโ€ directed at Johnson, the court said.

The appeals court reversed Coffee's denial of the recusal motion and said that a new judge should be reassigned.

Evans said Friday that he is pleased with the ruling and Johnson is looking forward to having his day in court.

Share This

Popular

Crime|Health|US

Columbine victim's death from health problems related to 1999 school shooting ruled a homicide

Columbine victim's death from health problems related to 1999 school shooting ruled a homicide
Crime|Education|MidEast|Political|US

Jewish protesters flood Trump Tower's lobby to demand Mahmoud Khalil's release

Jewish protesters flood Trump Tower's lobby to demand Mahmoud Khalil's release
Americas|Crime|Political|World

Haiti gangs set fire to building once home to nation's oldest radio station

Haiti gangs set fire to building once home to nation's oldest radio station
Americas|Crime|World

Mexicans hope uncovered mass grave sheds light on missing relatives

Mexicans hope uncovered mass grave sheds light on missing relatives

Crime

Crime|US

Utah judge orders release of suspect in 1977 Hawaii killing after prosecution stalls

Utah judge orders release of suspect in 1977 Hawaii killing after prosecution stalls
Crime|US

Man describes cruelty during his two decades of captivity at his family home in Connecticut

Man describes cruelty during his two decades of captivity at his family home in Connecticut
Business|Crime|Food|Political|US

Restaurant owner reunites with family after being released from detention center on bond

Restaurant owner reunites with family after being released from detention center on bond
Crime|Education|MidEast|Political|US|World

Protesters occupy Trump Tower following arrest of Columbia student

Protesters occupy Trump Tower following arrest of Columbia student

Access this article for free.

Already have an account? Sign In