The Los Angeles Post
U.S. World Business Lifestyle
Today: April 23, 2025
Today: April 23, 2025

Supreme Court declines to halt execution over religious claims as Gorsuch joins liberals in dissent

Supreme Court declines to halt execution over religious claims as Gorsuch joins liberals in dissent
March 18, 2025
John Fritze - CNN

(CNN) โ€” A sharply divided Supreme Court declined Tuesday to halt the execution of a death row inmate in Louisiana who argued that the use of nitrogen gas would interfere with his Buddhist beliefs โ€“ an argument that drew interest from one of the courtโ€™s conservatives.

Jessie Hoffman claimed that the stateโ€™s method of execution would interfere with his ability to engage in meditative breathing as he died, a practice his lawyers told the Supreme Court โ€œcarries profound spiritual significance.โ€

As is often the case on its emergency docket, the Supreme Court did not explain its reasoning for denying Hoffmanโ€™s request to halt his execution. However, Justice Neil Gorsuch, a conservative, joined with the courtโ€™s three liberals in dissenting from the decision.

Gorsuch, among the courtโ€™s most outspoken defenders of religious rights, said that lower courts should have looked more closely at Hoffmanโ€™s religious claim. Gorsuch said he would have sent the case back to the New Orleans-based 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals for reconsideration.

โ€œPerhaps that claim ultiยญmately lacks merit,โ€ Gorsuch wrote. โ€œBut the Fifth Circuitโ€™s unexplained omission leaves this court poorly positioned to assess it.โ€

Hoffman was convicted in the 1996 murder of Mary โ€œMollyโ€ Elliott.

The Supreme Court has, at times, made religious accommodations for death row inmates. In 2022, for instance, the court ruled that a Texas death row inmate could have his spiritual adviser pray aloud and โ€œlay handsโ€ on him during his execution.

Louisiana carried out the execution later Tuesday, Hoffmanโ€™s attorney said.

โ€œTonight, the State of Louisiana carried out the senseless execution of Jessie Hoffman,โ€ attorney Cecelia Kappel said in a statement. โ€œHe was a father, a husband, and a man who showed extraordinary capacity for redemption.โ€

This story has been updated with additional reporting.

The-CNN-Wire
โ„ข & ยฉ 2025 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

Share This

Popular

Crime

Tampa man arrested on suspicion of restraining 11-year-old girl he claimed was egging his home

Tampa man arrested on suspicion of restraining 11-year-old girl he claimed was egging his home
Crime|Political|US|World

Lawyers ask federal judge in Vermont for immediate release of detained Palestinian activist

Lawyers ask federal judge in Vermont for immediate release of detained Palestinian activist
Crime|Political|World

Disputed Kashmir witnesses deadliest attack on civilians in years, sparking fears of rising tensions

Disputed Kashmir witnesses deadliest attack on civilians in years, sparking fears of rising tensions
Crime|Political|World

Antisemitic incidents slow worldwide from post-Oct. 7 spike, but remain higher than before Gaza war

Antisemitic incidents slow worldwide from post-Oct. 7 spike, but remain higher than before Gaza war

Political

Business|Economy|Political|US

Trump was warned of financial turmoil if he fired Powell. Now, his U-turn has stocks roaring higher

Trump was warned of financial turmoil if he fired Powell. Now, his U-turn has stocks roaring higher
Opinion|Political

Justice Department lawyers work for justice and the Constitution โ€“ not the White House

Justice Department lawyers work for justice and the Constitution โ€“ not the White House
Crime|Political|US|World

Lawyers ask federal judge in Vermont for immediate release of detained Palestinian activist

Lawyers ask federal judge in Vermont for immediate release of detained Palestinian activist
Opinion|Political|Technology

From help to harm: How the government is quietly repurposing everyoneโ€™s data for surveillance

From help to harm: How the government is quietly repurposing everyoneโ€™s data for surveillance